Google Gears Up for NFC M-Commerce; Wallet War Ahead?

As Google’s outgoing CEO Eric Schmidt put it at last month’s Mobile World Congress, NFC combined with smartphones represents a "mega-scale opportunity" and promises to "revolutionize" electronic commerce and payments.

Google has been gearing up to take advantage of that opportunity. I’m told it has been contacting a number of large U.S. merchants, including Wal-Mart, to get buy-in for its plan to push location-based mobile marketing and advertising to consumers, who could then tap their Android NFC phones using a Google-developed mobile wallet.

Google also has been putting together a team of payment and other mobile-commerce professionals, as it continues to build the wallet and the foundation for the cloud-based apps that would pinpoint a consumer’s location, know his interests and tap to collect and redeem offers and pay with NFC–with the consumer’s opt-in, of course.

And the Web giant has been working with big U.S. acquirer and processor First Data, which could provide connections with potentially millions of merchants, including small and medium size retailers throughout the United States. First Data also has introduced a trusted service management offer, and Google, I’m told, is interested in using it for applications downloaded to the wallet, perhaps for its own services or those of its partners.

Google also has been rumored to be in discussions with contactless reader maker Vivotech and point-of-sale terminal vendors, such as VeriFone. Along with First Data, these hardware vendors would provide the vital links between merchants and Google’s mobile-commerce platform when Android-users tap at the point of sale.

But everything I’ve heard from people who do more than just guess about Google’s–or for that matter, Apple’s–plans for NFC says neither wants to face the uphill battle of launching its own payment scheme at the physical point of sale.

Instead, they would build NFC-enabled digital wallets for their smartphone operating platforms, in which payment service providers, including banks, could store their applications. Apple’s wallet plans are less certain, despite a recent patent application with an e-wallet icon on the home screen.

But Google is definitely working on the phone software, code named "Cream," which was due out by April but might be delayed until early summer.

NFC Payment is a critical component in Google’s grand m-commerce plans because it consummates the consumer’s relationship with merchants that Google hopes to broker through its targeted mobile promotions and access to consumers when they are in or near the retail outlet. This targeted access is what Google would be selling to merchants. Besides that, the payment transactions would gather data on consumers’ buying habits for the next round of promotions, again, with the consumer’s permission.

"For Google, the opportunity is not the 1.5% they would receive for payment. The opportunity is the 10%-plus they get for referring the sale to the merchant. That’s why the payment business isn’t interesting (for Google)," said one observer of the Web giant’s moves in NFC.

The company made more than 95% of its $29.3 billion in sales last year from Web advertising. It wants that revenue flow to continue unabated as consumers do more and more browsing and search queries on their smartphones.

And smartphones combined with NFC could give Google something it lacks on the fixed Internet–access to physical merchants–where the vast majority of commerce is done. This is probably the crux of the mega-scale opportunity Schmidt was talking about.

Potential access to millions of physical merchants and targeted offers were likely the main things Google was after when it made its mega-bid for deal-of-the-day e-commerce site Groupon. Groupon, however, rejected the $6 billion offer late last year.

"Wouldn’t Google love to find a Groupon killer with something you could redeem at point of sale?" Todd Ablowitz, president of the U.S.-based Double Diamond consulting firm, told me.

He could not say whom he thinks Google might work with for the payment or other pieces of its m-commerce platform anchored by NFC phones.

Are Citi and MasterCard Onboard?
But I’m getting strong signals that a Citigroup-issued MasterCard PayPass application would be among the first payment card accounts in a Google wallet.

Citi is the only one of the top five U.S. banks not working on contactless microSD cards—at least not that we know of. Of course, Citi mostly works with MasterCard, which only recently gained access to the products of the main vendor supplying contactless microSDs for payment at present, DeviceFidelity. The vendor had had an exclusive deal with Visa Inc.

But unlike such Citi rivals as Bank of America, which appears to favor microSDs or other NFC alternatives, Citi has been among the strongest backers among U.S. banks of full NFC.

Yet, up until now, besides a rather anemic launch of a passive contactless sticker carrying a PayPass application last spring, Citi has done nothing in contactless-mobile payment stateside since an NFC trial it launched with MasterCard in New York City in 2007.

That absence is despite bubbly statements by a Citi executive about how much customers love NFC. Some execs made the same noise after a large NFC trial in Bangalore, India, in 2009.

Of course, compelling NFC phones will only become available this year. And Google is not the only platform or device supplier that is working on a mobile wallet.

If Citi, in fact, is going to be part of the Google wallet, it would bring MasterCard along. If nothing else, MasterCard would help to fund Citi’s implementation.

MasterCard also would be more flexible than Visa Inc. in working with new players in the payment industry. And the card network has been preparing for the coming of full NFC.

In January, it hired Mung-Ki Woo, in part for his direct experience in handling NFC projects with mobile operator France Telecom-Orange Group.

Referring to plans by some mobile operators to introduce their own payment brands using NFC phones, Woo told me earlier this month that MasterCard is "prepared to enter a dialogue" with the telcos.

"They will yield more business benefits by working with MasterCard than trying to sort of reinvent the wheel," he said. "Proximity payment is a complex domain."

MasterCard, like Citi, First Data and the POS terminal and reader vendors are not confirming plans that they are working directly with Google.

Wallet War Ahead?
Google seems to agree that it doesn’t pay to launch its own payment scheme. But it will be interesting to see how Google’s wallet stacks up against the wallets planned by three of the four major U.S. mobile carriers, AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile USA.

The U.S. telcos plan their own payment brand, Isis, which will anchor the wallets. So a Google wallet, at least in theory, could reside on the same Android phone as an Isis wallet.

But which secure element would any Citi-MasterCard PayPass payment applet be loaded on as part of a Google wallet? Would it go onto an embedded chip or possibly the SIM card, the latter directly controlled by mobile operators? Who will control the embedded secure chip in these Android and other NFC phones?

Schmidt, who will step aside next month as Google CEO and become executive chairman, did not discuss this issue in his relatively brief comments about NFC during his keynote at the Mobile World Congress last month in Barcelona. But he did seem to lump the contactless NFC chip in with the secure chip, speaking of it as one unit. Was he talking about an embedded chip?

The first Android NFC phone on the market, Google’s Nexus S, made by Samsung and released in December, has an embedded chip but also supports NFC applications on SIM cards–though the application-programming interface for payment using NFC’s card-emulation mode is not yet part of Android. The same architecture is expected for the forthcoming Samsung flagship Android phone, the Galaxy S II.

Some observers believe the U.S. carriers would want to hold the keys to all secure elements in the NFC phones they sell, including those for embedded chips. But these keys would be in the control of the handset makers, unless telcos are able to insist the phone makers hand over the master keys after the phones leave the factory.

"The fundamental question is, can smartphone vendors embed NFC in the phone and launch NFC services and still have the carrier sell phones to customers?" one observer remarked to me.

The battle over the secure element in NFC phones that has simmered for years between mobile operators and banks now seems to have some new contenders–Google and the Android handset makers, as well as Nokia-Microsoft, Research in Motion with its planned BlackBerry NFC phones and, of course, Apple, though it's not clear whether the latter will adopt NFC for the next iPhone. The secure chip in NFC phones will become an important piece of real estate, supporting potentially lucrative applications, such as payment, and the corresponding apps in the platform providers' app stores.

But with Google planning to launch its NFC wallet as early as this spring–one of the first real shots in that battle could be fired soon. 

Article comments

 
mroyer1 May 26 2011

They should have called it "Google Charge" -- much better, catchier, name. That is unless they plan to use that for all their new energy initiatives.

Mark Royer
Knowledge Solutions

Please register or login to post a comment.

HEADLINE NEWS

Study: Merchants Could Boost Sales by Easing Fears Over Digital Security

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – A survey conducted by American Express suggests that U.S. merchants could increase their online sales by taking steps to enhance the security of customers' information.

EU Antitrust Regulators Launch In-Depth Investigation into Qualcomm’s Planned NXP Acquisition

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – European Union antitrust regulators have launched an in-depth review of Qualcomm’s planned $47 billion acquisition of NXP Semiconductors, the largest supplier of NFC controllers and secure elements globally.

Visa Expands Token Service Provider ‘Partner’ Program, Though Most Vendors Not Yet Integrated with VTS

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight ­– Visa this week announced a new list of 13 “partner” companies to help it distribute and manage Visa-generated tokens, which the network giant is promoting for use in what it hopes will be large-scale rollouts of Internet of Things devices that can do payments.

Analysis: Apple Apparently Sees Need for Additional Pairing Technology with Support for NFC Tag Reading

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight ­– Nearly three years after embracing NFC technology for mobile payments but declining to support NFC’s tag-reading mode, Apple, in a surprise move, is adding tag-reading support to its NFC-enabled devices, including the iPhone 7 series and forthcoming iPhone 8, as well as its Apple Watch.

Exclusive: Major U.S. Processors Say In-Store Transactions for Pays Wallets Remain Disappointing

NFC TIMES Exclusive – Apple Pay and the other major Pays wallets still only account for around 1% of card transactions in the U.S., three major processors told NFC Times. At least two of the processors say they haven’t seen growth in Apple Pay over at least the past year.

Alipay North America Chief Insists Company has No Plans for U.S.-Based Wallet

NFC TIMES Exclusive –  Alipay has no plans today to introduce a mobile wallet in the U.S., and is instead expanding its merchant acceptance footprint in the U.S. only to serve Chinese visitors, Souheil Badran, president of Alipay North America, told NFC Times.

NFC Secure Element Shipments Likely Dropped for First Time in 2016, and Vendor Group Cuts Forecast for 2017

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Shipments of NFC secure elements almost certainly fell in 2016, based on recent figures released by vendor association Eurosmart, though the group is again declining to release specific shipment figures for NFC cards and embedded chips, instead combining the NFC unit shipments with those for machine-to-machine modules.

Samsung Pay Launches Commercially in Taiwan; No. 4 Credit Card Issuer Taishin Reveals Apple Pay Card Adds

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Samsung made it official, launching Samsung Pay commercially today in Taiwan with seven banks, as expected, following Apple Pay to the market by about two months and beating Android Pay, which is expected to launch on the island nation as early as next week. 

Why is Mobile Wallet Adoption So Disappointing? Some Industry Players Weigh In

NFC TIMES Exclusive –  NFC wallets are failing to catch on in the U.S., especially for in-store transactions, for a variety of reasons, including poor awareness among consumers and cashiers, lack of full buy-in from merchants, problems with certifying terminals for contactless and an insufficient value proposition, said industry players, including a representative from Google.

Samsung Pay Launches in UK Without Major Banks or MST Technology

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Samsung today finally launched its Samsung Pay mobile payments service in the UK, well behind rival payments services Apple Pay and Android Pay.

Wal-Mart Still Balks at Accepting NFC; Nordstrom Wants Right to Refuse Some NFC Wallets

NFC TIMES Exclusive – LAS VEGAS, Nev.: It’s been more than two and a half years since Apple Pay launched in the U.S., and retail giant Wal-Mart Stores still is no closer to accepting NFC at its 4,000-plus stores in the U.S. then when Apple began rolling out its NFC-enabled mobile payments service in October of 2014.

Apple Testing Loyalty Feature; Google Expected to Expand Payments for Home Device

NFC TIMES Exclusive – As they struggle with low user adoption of their respective wallets in the U.S., Apple and Google are seeking to add more features, hoping to increase transactions, NFC Times has learned.