U.S. Telcos Advance NFC Mobile-Payment Project

May 25 2010

A consortium of major U.S. mobile operators continues to make preparations for launching mobile-payment services to subscribers, although one operator in the group, Sprint, is pulling back from the project, sources told NFC Times.

Details of the project remain confidential, but sources said the other three telcos, Verizon, AT&T and T-Mobile USA, are laying the groundwork for introducing mobile payment and other applications using full NFC phones and possibly other contactless technologies. The telcos have formalized their partnership in a joint venture and continue to try to recruit a CEO to lead the group, NFC Times has learned.

“All three carriers, AT&T, T-Mobile and Verizon, are making real moves to real NFC, focused on mobile payments but not limited to that,” a source told NFC Times.

Sprint is no longer taking an active role in the project and may have pulled out altogether, which observers chalk up to the telco’s need to focus on its core business to try to stem the hundreds of millions of dollars in losses it has been incurring every quarter. Sprint had been in charge of developing the technology for the project.

As NFC Times first reported in February, the major U.S. operators see an opportunity to get into the retail payments business and capture a substantial share of transaction revenue from merchants by equipping their subscribers with NFC phones and possibly such peripherals as contactless stickers, microSD cards or SIMs with flexible antennas.

They have been discussing the project for as long as two years, but according to one source, sealed the joint venture with a more formal contract only within the past two weeks. They are also making progress on choosing a trusted service manager to download and manage secure applications on the phones.

The telcos would also introduce other applications, such as loyalty programs, ticketing and access control, said sources. They said the NFC phones would store the secure applications either on SIM cards or in embedded chips in the handsets

A launch date–if the project goes forward–likely wouldn’t happen until late this year or early next year, though it might be announced before that. To hit that kind of launch schedule, the telcos will have had to have ordered NFC phones by now or to do so soon. Few NFC phones are currently available.

In addition to full NFC, at least one of the carriers, AT&T, has expressed interest in contactless peripherals for phones.

NFC Times has learned AT&T floated a request for information earlier this year on passive stickers, which subscribers could attach to the back of their phones and tap to pay as they would contactless cards. According to a source, who has seen the request, AT&T appeared to be considering putting a Zip contactless application on the stickers, which would mean it would be working with Discover Financial Services.

Business Model Up in the Air?
But it remains unclear whether the carriers are planning to try to launch their own payment scheme to take on the big U.S. banks and card networks Visa Inc. and MasterCard Worldwide; or would instead partner with card networks and banks to offer cobranded products. Some sources speculate the telcos are split among themselves about whether to launch their own scheme.

A cobranded model, in which the mobile operators would roll out both payment cards and mobile applications with partner banks, would still allow the telcos to collect some transaction-fee revenue from merchants. But it would not entail building a new payment network.

“There’s lots of risk (with a new scheme), and carriers don’t know anything about payment networks,” said one industry source with knowledge of the project.

Others speculate the telcos wouldn’t order millions of NFC phones or lay the foundation for introducing mobile payment if they weren’t planning something big, to wit: a payment scheme of their own to compete with Visa and MasterCard. They could then collect nearly all of the transaction revenue for themselves.

With almost 200 million subscribers between them, any move by Verizon and AT&T into retail payments is cause for concern among banks.

Sources from the banking industry note that mobile operators in both the U.S. and abroad have long been covetous of the payments revenue of banks. But they have never been able to capture a significant market share in the places they’ve tried. Among other things, launching a new payment system requires a large base of merchants accepting the new payment brand and expertise in managing risk, neither of which mobile operators have, say the sources.

Some U.S banks are embarking on their own mobile-payment initiatives.

Banks Look to Contactless Peripherals
For example, as NFC Times reported last month, Citigroup is launching a passive sticker, which customers could attach to their phones or other devices. The bank has yet to announce the product, which was expected by the end of April, raising speculation of production delays. 

UPDATE: “The stickers are currently available to customers who request them,” Kurt Weiss, a senior vice president in the Citi Cards unit and head of global mobile strategy, said in a statement to NFC Times

UPDATE: Citi declined to comment directly on possible delays, but a source close to the bank said there were no problems with production of the sticker, which supports a MasterCard PayPass application. Citi has posted a new Web page for its soft launch of the product.

The sticker is being launched through Citi’s U.S. cards division, and the bank, especially its growth ventures unit, has expressed strong interest in moving beyond trials. Citi has held at least four NFC trials worldwide.

Stickers and contactless microSDs have attracted the attention of banks because the peripherals could enable them to introduce contactless-mobile payment to customers while largely bypassing the telcos.

Visa has been promoting a contactless microSD card from U.S.-based DeviceFidelity, which it will field test with banks later this year following employee trials. The tiny flash memory cards will carry a Visa payWave contactless application, which subscribers could insert into microSD slots on handsets–turning the phones into payment devices. A special attachment would also enable users of Apple’s iPhone to tap their phones to pay at payWave point-of-sale terminals. The iPhone doesn’t have its own microSD slot. 

“The banks are trying to figure out a way to circumvent the carriers, and now the carriers are trying to find a way to circumvent the banks,” said an observer.

Perhaps the biggest challenge for mobile operators attempting to launch their own payment scheme would be signing up enough merchants to accept the new form of payment.

Targeting Wal-Mart?
The speculation is that the telcos would try to slash interchange fees to attract big, high-profile, merchants unhappy with the fees banks charge and which are set by the major card schemes. That would include the biggest of merchant of them all, Wal-Mart Stores Inc., the world’s largest retailer, with revenue of more than $405 billion in the last fiscal year.

One payments industry consultant suggested the mobile operators could cut interchange fees by more than half compared with the rate Visa has set for signature debit transactions. The lower fees would also be substantially below Visa’s less costly PIN-based debit interchange rate. If the telcos were to introduce a credit payment application as well, they would have even more room to undercut the major card schemes. They might also launch a prepaid application.

Wal-Mart, which has said it does not accept contactless cards because it sees no economic benefit in doing so, just might be enticed to join the carrier’s NFC-enabled payment scheme if fees were substantially lower, said observers. “You probably have critical mass just with Wal-Mart,” said the consultant. Wal-Mart has more than 4,300 supercenters, discount department stores, warehouse stores and neighborhood markets in the U.S.

He believes other big chains could also be encouraged to join, such as consumer electronics giant Best Buy and home improvement retailer Home Depot, both of which already accept contactless and which also complain about interchange.

Jamie Henry, Wal-Mart’s director of payment services, briefly mentioned during his presentation at the Smart Card Alliance conference last week in Scottsdale, Arizona, that mobile payment could lower costs for Wal-Mart. When asked to explain afterward, he suggested to NFC Times that there could be alternative payment schemes that are lower in cost than the existing card brands.

But talk of Wal-Mart supporting a new payment scheme is only speculation for now, John Drechny, Wal-Mart’s senior director of payment services, told NFC Times.

“We’re always looking for a way to lower our cost, so we will talk to anyone that has an idea to achieve that,” he said.

It’s true that any partnership between the mobile operators and Wal-Mart or other parties remains speculation. But what is clear is that the largest mobile operators continue to lay the groundwork for a possible move into the U.S. payments market.

As one banking industry source put it: In contrast to the noise the telcos made in the past about entering the payments market, this time, “no doubt, it seems more serious.”

HEADLINE NEWS

In-Depth: NFC Wallet Use for Open-Loop Transit Grows but Still Makes Up Relatively Small Share of Contactless Payments

NFC TIMES Exclusive – When New York City transit officials announced Tuesday that the 1 millionth ride paid for through their new OMNY open-loop payments service had arrived ahead of schedule, they also proudly noted that 80% of the contactless payments had come from NFC wallets, not physical bank cards. 

PayPay Gets Off to Quick Start as One of Many Digital Payments Services in Cash-Loving Japan

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – As Japan continues to fight what to date has been a losing battle against cash, an announcement by the joint venture behind QR code-based payments service PayPay offers a little bit of encouragement. 

Research Firm Projects Use of NFC Mobile Wallets in U.S. to Remain Disappointing This Year

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – As Apple Pay approaches the fifth anniversary of its launch in the U.S., there is more research showing that most American consumers simply don’t see the value of tapping to pay with NFC-based payments services. 

In-Depth: Five Years After Transport for London Launched Contactless Across Its Transit Network, UK Open-Loop Rollout Remains Uneven

Aug 15 2019

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Five years ago next month, Transport for London introduced open-loop contactless payments across its transit network, including metro, trams and commuter rail, following an earlier launch on buses. The service now accounts for more than half of all pay-as-you-go journeys and has become a global showcase for the technology.

Apple Again Promises to Push Transit Ticketing as It Seeks Broader Adoption of Apple Pay

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – While noting to financial analysts late Tuesday that Apple Pay is now approaching 1 billion transactions per month globally and is in 47 markets, perhaps Apple CEO Tim Cook’s most significant comments about Apple Pay this week was to again emphasize that Apple wants to enable users to routinely tap to pay for bus, subway and other transit rides with their iPhones and Apple Watches. 

Chinese Mega Wallets Continue to Expand QR Code-based Transit Ticketing, while Major Agencies in West Stay with NFC

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight ­– China’s mega-mobile wallet providers have continued their rollouts of transit payments in China, with Tencent Holdings announcing Tuesday that two years after launching its first QR-code-based WeChat “Ride Code” service in Guangzhou, total users for its transit payments services has reached 100 million.

Sydney Transit Authority Gives Users of Contactless Bank Cards Nearly All Discounts They Get with Closed-Loop Opal Cards

Jul 29 2019

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Transport for New South Wales, Australia, the authority that oversees transit in and around Sydney, has taken a step toward phasing out its closed-loop contactless Opal fare card, today extending nearly all of the discounts it offers on Opal to users of open-loop Visa- Mastercard- and American Express-branded contactless cards.

In-Depth: 2020 Could Mark Landmark Year for Contactless Payments in U.S.

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight– October will mark the fifth anniversary of the launch of Apple Pay in the U.S., Apple’s first country for its groundbreaking NFC payments service. 

Filings Point to Plans for Global Expansion of Apple Card and Apple Cash

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Following Apple’s imminent entry into the credit card business in the U.S. with its planned Apple Card, the tech giant is showing signs it is looking to roll out the branded credit card in a number of other countries, as well.

Analysis: It's Likely Too Little, Too Late for LG Pay

Jul 25 2019

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – It was the fall of 2015, and interest in the Pays wallets was burgeoning. Google and Samsung had each launched their respective payments services in September of 2015 in the U.S., following introduction of Apple Pay a year earlier.

Apple Pay to Finally Support Octopus Card in Hong Kong, as Competition Grows in Market

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight –  Apple Pay will offer support for Hong Kong’s popular closed-loop contactless transit and retail payments card Octopus later this year, adding a much-needed service to an Apple Wallet that launched three years ago in Hong Kong for credit and debit payments at retail.

Visa Promotes QR Codes in Contactless Hot Spot Taiwan, Hoping to Capture Merchants That Refuse to Accept Cards

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – While Visa’s country office in Taiwan was touting the fact that Taiwan ranks as one of the top countries in Asia Pacific for acceptance and use of contactless payments only six months ago, that hasn’t stopped the big payments network from actively promoting QR code payments on the island nation, too.